
Feeder Wagon vs Mixer Wagon for Your Operation
In the feeder wagon vs mixer wagon comparison, choose a feeder wagon when you mainly need to carry and unload feed, and consider a mixer wagon when you prepare a multi-ingredient ration on site. A feeder wagon moves and spreads what you load into it. A mixer wagon blends ingredients into one ration before unloading. That difference drives most of the buying decision.
Feeder Wagon vs Mixer Wagon for Your Operation
In the feeder wagon vs mixer wagon comparison, choose a feeder wagon when you mainly need to carry and unload feed, and consider a mixer wagon when you prepare a multi-ingredient ration on site. A feeder wagon moves and spreads what you load into it. A mixer wagon blends ingredients into one ration before unloading. That difference drives most of the buying decision.
What Is a Feeder Wagon and What Is a Mixer Wagon?
A feeder wagon is a towed box with a floor conveyor or auger that moves feed to a discharge opening. You load hay, silage, grain or a premixed ration, pull the wagon along the bunk line, and the drive system delivers feed at a steady rate. Blending is limited. If you want some mixing, you load in layers so the materials travel out together. Apache lists several sizes in its feeder wagon product line, including models with a dolly front end and models with a fold-up tongue. Lengths, capacities and axle setups vary by model, so confirm the figures with your dealer.
A mixer wagon actively blends several ingredients into a total mixed ration, or TMR, before unloading. Its purpose is ration mixing rather than simple feed delivery. Confirm the mixing system, weight and tractor requirements for the specific model with a dealer.
Feeder Wagon vs Mixer Wagon Differences in Daily Use
The difference shows up in your morning routine. With a cattle feeder wagon, you load a feedstuff or a ration someone else already mixed, then drive and unload. The job is hauling and placing feed. With a feed mixer wagon, loading is the first step of a recipe. You add each ingredient in a set order and let the machine blend before you discharge.
| Factor | Feeder wagon | Mixer wagon |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Haul and unload feed | Blend a ration, then unload |
| Blending | Little to none; layer the load | Active mixing |
| Common feed | Hay, silage, grain, premixed feed | Multi-ingredient TMR |
| Daily routine | Load, drive, discharge | Load by recipe, mix, discharge |
Which Suits a Ranch and Which Suits a Feeding Operation?
Cow-Calf and Grass-Based Ranches
A feeder wagon for ranch use fits operations that feed hay, silage or a simple supplement through winter. If your cows get roughage plus a bagged or bulk supplement, you may not need a machine that blends. You need one that carries a day of feed and lays it out along your portable and permanent feed bunks. Match the wagon and discharge setup to your bunk layout so the dealer can help you plan the feeding route.
Backgrounding Yards and Feedlots
A mixer wagon for cattle may suit a feeding operation that prepares a multi-ingredient ration on site. Compare your ration ingredients, mixing frequency, available tractor and daily feeding routine with a dealer before choosing a mixer wagon.
Operations in the Middle
Plenty of operations sit between these two. A farm that runs cows and also backgrounds a load of calves may feed a mixed ration part of the year and plain hay the rest. In that case, compare the cost of mixing yourself against buying a premixed ration and hauling it with a simpler wagon.
What Do You Need to Run One?
Start with the power source and requirements for the specific model you are considering. Your dealer can compare those requirements with the equipment you already use. Check these points before you shop:
- Tractor power. Ask the dealer for the required PTO and tractor specifications for each model you compare.
- Hitch and tongue. Apache lists feeder wagon models with dolly front ends and fold-up tongues. Ask which front-end option fits your route, storage space and tractor.
- Loading equipment. You need a loader, skid steer or grapple that can reach the top of the box.
- Storage and clearance. Measure gate widths, alley turns and the shed bay where the wagon will sit.
- Route conditions. Discuss your feeding route, ground conditions and expected load with a dealer when comparing models.
Ask your dealer for the specification sheet for the exact model, then compare its capacity, dimensions and power requirements with your tractor and feeding route.
How Do You Choose a Model?
Work through the decision in order rather than starting from a model number.
- Write down your ration. A simple feed program may favor a feeder wagon, while a multi-ingredient ration prepared on site may call for a mixer wagon.
- Count the cattle and the loads. Decide how many head you feed at once and how many trips per day you are willing to make.
- Check the tractor. Confirm PTO speed, available horsepower, hydraulics and hitch type on the tractor that will pull the wagon daily.
- Measure your route. Walk the path from storage to the bunk line and note the tightest gate and the softest ground.
- Compare models with a dealer. Ask for spec sheets on two or three candidates in the right size class.
- Plan for service. Ask about wear parts, drive components and parts availability before you sign.
Questions to Ask Your Dealer
- What capacity does this model hold, and how does that compare with my daily feed volume?
- What PTO horsepower and hitch does it require, loaded and in field conditions?
- Which discharge style fits my bunks, and can it unload from the side I feed on?
- What are the overall length, width and height for storage and travel?
- Which wear parts are serviced most often, and how are they stocked?
- Can I see the brochure and manual for this model before I decide?
You can review the catalog and product brochures through the Apache literature and manuals resources, and compare blending machines on the mixer wagon category page.
Frequently asked questions
Can a feeder wagon mix feed at all?
Do I need a mixer wagon to feed a total mixed ration?
Which costs less to own over time?
What size tractor do I need?
How does bunk design affect my choice?
Where can I buy Apache feeding equipment?
Making the Decision
Start with your ration, not the machine. If you feed one or two roughages and a simple supplement, a feeder wagon may fit the job. If you build a ration from several ingredients on site, a mixer wagon is the tool. Then confirm that your tractor, loader, gates and storage suit the size you want, and ask your dealer for the spec sheet before you commit.
For a feeder wagon vs mixer wagon decision, Apache Equipment manufactures livestock feeding, handling and hay equipment built and assembled in America with domestic and globally sourced components, and sold through dealers. To compare feeding equipment and request literature, visit Apache Equipment.
Continue Reading
More from the Apache blog
EquipmentWhen to Use a Range Feeder for Cattle on Pasture
A range feeder for cattle is equipment used to keep supplemental feed available to a cow herd out on pasture, instead of hauling the herd back to a lot to feed.
EquipmentCattle Mineral Feeder and Oiler Types and Placement
A cattle mineral feeder is a pasture station that holds loose mineral or salt so cattle can eat it free choice, meaning they take what they want when they want it.